دانلود مقاله انگلیسی رایگان:اثبات قابلیت اطمینان از طریق شفافیت: یک چارچوب اعتبار علمی برای کمک به دانشمندان و حقوقدانان در دادرسی کیفری - 2020
بلافاصله پس از پرداخت دانلود کنید 2
دانلود مقاله انگلیسی حقوق خصوصی رایگان
  • Demonstrating reliability through transparency: A scientific validity framework to assist scientists and lawyers in criminal proceedings Demonstrating reliability through transparency: A scientific validity framework to assist scientists and lawyers in criminal proceedings
    Demonstrating reliability through transparency: A scientific validity framework to assist scientists and lawyers in criminal proceedings

    سال انتشار:

    2020


    عنوان انگلیسی مقاله:

    Demonstrating reliability through transparency: A scientific validity framework to assist scientists and lawyers in criminal proceedings


    ترجمه فارسی عنوان مقاله:

    اثبات قابلیت اطمینان از طریق شفافیت: یک چارچوب اعتبار علمی برای کمک به دانشمندان و حقوقدانان در دادرسی کیفری


    منبع:

    Sciencedirect - Elsevier - Forensic Science International, 308 (2020) 110110. doi:10.1016/j.forsciint.2019.110110


    نویسنده:

    S. Carra,*, E. Piaseckib, A. Gallopc


    چکیده انگلیسی:

    In recent decades, forensic science evidence has come to play an increasingly significant role in criminal proceedings. However, the ability of non-scientists (lay-persons, including lawyers and judges) within criminal justice systems to recognise and resolve issues of validity and reliability relating to expert opinion evidence has not maintained pace with the need to do so. Despite international scrutiny from scientists, statisticians, governments and those involved in law reform, the parameters of a) different forensic disciplines and b) some case specific interpretations, remain elusive to some legal practitioners and judges. It is therefore essential that within the context of national, and increasingly international and transnational criminal investigations, forensic science experts convey the evidential value of the scientific findings in a manner that is understandable to, and useable by all. To assist, this paper first identifies the organisational structures necessary to scaffold and support the delivery of reliable expert opinion evidence. This is followed by a format for transparently reporting the reasoning and the scientific validity underpinning the expert’s evidence within their report: a tripartite Scientific Validity Framework. This framework is comprised of (i) foundational validity, (ii) applied validity and (iii) the new concept of evaluative validity. Such a framework, because of its underlying scientific principles, is applicable to expert reports in any jurisdiction and is complementary to different national approaches. That is because utilising this framework could ensure that experts can, and do, demonstrate that their case-specific opinion is reliable and alert the legal profession to the expert’s reasoning process and any limitations in the scientific validity underpinning the opinion
    Keywords: Expert opinion evidence | Scientific validity | Critical trust | Reliability


    سطح: متوسط
    تعداد صفحات فایل pdf انگلیسی: 6
    حجم فایل: 411 کیلوبایت

    قیمت: رایگان


    توضیحات اضافی:




اگر این مقاله را پسندیدید آن را در شبکه های اجتماعی به اشتراک بگذارید (برای به اشتراک گذاری بر روی ایکن های زیر کلیک کنید)

تعداد نظرات : 0

الزامی
الزامی
الزامی
rss مقالات ترجمه شده rss مقالات انگلیسی rss کتاب های انگلیسی rss مقالات آموزشی
logo-samandehi